Wednesday, October 19, 2011

PHILOSOPHICAL CHAIRS Debrief

PREP -
*better question so that the student are split more equally;
*more time and possibly a number of facts that they have to have in order to participate-- those who do not have that number or don't have prep notes have to stay in the undecided/question section
* more time for additional resources to be found (homework?)

DURING
*watch people speaking -- be sure to be strict about the limits and keep the pro/con/question folks in the loop
*give tickets for talking/check with points as extra way to add items to the essay portion at the end?
*undecided/unprepared can only ask one question unless they class is not split

ADAPTATIONS
*if class is not split, then adjust the rules about speaking allowing those who want to ask a question (so they can get their points to join or create a question section and an undecided section


Collect both papers at the end. If students spoke, they need to star the points from the prep day and put the points on the second paper -- that way if the instructor misses someone, they will have it marked.

The next day ask about the process including
*what worked, didn't work?
*what could have made the experience better for you as a student? as a participant?
*what would you have done to better prepare?
*what was different with this as opposed to just presenting information?
*what did you like/dislike about the process?
*how did you prepare differently for this than you would have for a regular presentation?

NEXT DAY - Review the process and introduce the writing prompt and how it works. Explain how the notes will be used.

QUESTIONS - When do you introduce this? Beginning, middle and end of a unit with what adaptations? Can see this as a pre, during (for checking for understanding mid way to see any left over miscues) and then as a post for following up. Teacher pals?